Skip to main content

What People Are Saying About Susan

"I worked with Susan to sell my parents' condo in the Madison area and I can't recommend her highly enough. In addition to being super professional and having a strong knowledge of the local market, she also staged the condo beautifully, responded quickly to my questions, and even helped negotiate some tricky issues with the condo association. (Fortunately, she also has a wonderful sense of humor!) I also appreciated the way Susan helped coordinate the various contractors I needed for one small repair or another, especially since I live out of state and couldn't be there myself. I highly recommend Susan to anyone in the Madison area who's looking to buy or sell, and especially to someone who might need to do so while living out of town."
If you need to buy or sell a home in the Madison area, Susan Stoehr is THE person you want on your team. As first time homebuyers in early 2022, my husband and I didn't think we would be able to find a house we liked (and had most of what we wanted) and have an offer accepted with how crazy the market was at the time. Susan's experience and expertise were absolutely invaluable during our search. Her knowledge of the market and the Madison area, as well as contacts with other top tier professionals (mortgage companies, contractors for any home repair you can imagine, etc) was extremely helpful. She is reliable, responds quickly to emails/phone calls, and really has the client's best interest in mind. She was very flexible which was really appreciated given our busy work schedules. From my initial email to beyond our closing date, she took very good care of us and treated us like family. She is also a lovely person and a lot of fun to work with, which was really nice with how stressful home buying can be. With her help we were able to beat out 37 other offers to purchase a house we adore. If I ever need to buy or sell a house in the future in the Madison area, Susan will be my first call.
We've worked with Susan for 3 home purchases and 3 home sales, we have always valued her advice and suggestions. Our needs have evolved over the years and Susan is always attentive and flexible. One of our home sales had some unexpected challenge and Susan's professionalism and network truly made the sale a success. She made an extremely stressful situation manageable. We've recommended her to many friends and family and will continue to do so!
Selling the home my husband and I had loved for 45 years barely a year after his death was a tremendous challenge, but Susan was the perfect guide and partner for the task. She communicated clearly and honestly and responded quickly to all questions. She was sympathetic and good-humored. Above all, she was experienced, professional, and focused on getting the best possible result for me, which she did. Thank you, Susan!
We recently used Susan Stoehr Homes to sell our home of 38 years. Susan was professional, accessible, and responsive to our questions at all times throughout the process. She provided honest feedback and invaluable guidance in our decision making. But most of all, Susan is a pleasant person to work with. She knows the business of selling homes. We have no hesitation giving Susan Stoehr Homes our highest recommendation.
Susan was so great to work with when buying our home. She was very responsive and always had an answer for every question we asked. We found the perfect house for our family and I know it was because we had Susan on our side. We would highly recommend her for anyone selling or buying as she simply is the best!
Susan was absolutely wonderful when helping my wife & me purchase our first home. Her insight & connections to other useful contacts (mortgage lender, contractors, etc.) proved immensely valuable to us going through the first-time home-buying experience. Thank you so much for making our dream of owning our own home a reality, Susan!
Susan is amazing! We worked on a pretty tight timeline and she gave us step by step instructions to make sure we stayed on task. She was so patient with us and was so caring of our cats. She also was amazing with the staging and provided additional items so extra cost was minimal. Our house sold in less than 3 days! If I could give more stars, I would!
Susan was so great to work with! Recently, she expertly guided us through the process of selling our first home. Her quick response and superior market knowledge culminated in the receipt of multiple offers over asking and ultimately the sale of our home in just a few short days. We would highly recommend working with Susan and will certainly return to her for our real estate needs in the future!
We had the pleasure of working with Susan Stoehr on the sale of our mother's home in the Nakoma neighborhood of Madison, WI. Susan was fantastic to work with. In particular, she was always on the spot with communications, kept us totally informed all along the way, and always answered the call, text or email. Susan also brings a great professionalism, excellent eye for detail, and solid acumen for the market. Our process went off very fast and without a hitch. I don't often write reviews (unless they're really bad), but Susan deserves high praise.
Susan helped us buy our first home and was great to work with. She is really friendly and knows the market well -- she had a lot of helpful connections (e.g., other realtors, inspectors, mortgage broker, contractors for estimates, etc.). She listened to what we wanted, didn't mind that we ended up seeing a lot of places before making an offer, and was happy to give her advice or opinion, but never made us feel pressured. She stayed on top of everything that had to happen leading up to and during the closing process, and was great about keeping us in the loop. We feel lucky to have worked with Susan and recommend her highly.
Susan was terrific to work with! She is the one who found our dream hobby farm and also helped us with the hurdles of dealing with one owner who was out of the country. She stayed on top of things and helped us close at the time we wanted to, before year end. Thank you, Susan
Susan helped me sell my home for over asking. She helped stage my home and guide me through the selling process. I’m glad I went with Susan.
I have worked with Susan both as a buyer and seller in Madison WI, and to say that she goes "above and beyond" is a drastic understatement. Susan represents her clients as if she has a personal stake in the transaction at hand, and she adapts her approach to your needs.I can't recommend Susan enough. She is knowledgeable, responsive, patient, and a VERY effective negotiator. What's more is that she goes out of her way to ensure her clients' peace of mind and minimize the hassle of what is typically a very stressful experience.Susan gets my vote in EVERY category, but especially for:*First-time buyers who need a little higher level of expertise*Sellers in tricky sales situations (like COVID!)*Out-of-state and long-distance buyers/sellers requiring a little extra patience and support*Those who are new to Madison and need someone who knows the local market better than anyone elseSusan is a true professional and an incredible asset to her clients. Five stars!
I used Susan as a buying and selling agent for my East Madison condo. As a selling agent she came up with a plan to market and sell my condo and did everything she said she would do professionally and quickly. My condo sold in record time, so thanks Susan.
We have worked with Susan twice - once when buying a house as we moved from out of state and 7 years later when we sold that house. Susan was professional, friendly and super helpful both times. She answered all of our questions in a timely manner and was knowledgeable about different area of Madison and surrounding towns. Selling our house was seamless even during the pandemic. We would highly recommend Susan to anyone looking for a realtor.
Susan is a fantastic realtor! She helped me and my wife purchase our first home and the process was a breeze because of Susan. She was able to work well with our tight schedule to find a home. She was on top of every detail and very quick to respond to all of the questions my wife and I had. She walked us through every detail of the home buying experience along the way. She was able to negotiate with the buyers to have our contract include exactly what we were looking for. She seems very well connected to and knowledgeable of Madison and the surrounding areas. I would highly recommend her to anyone looking to purchase a home. Thank you, Susan!
Susan provides excellent service! She was with us throughout the process of selling our home, searching for a new one, and ultimately building our dream home. She gave us fantastic advice throughout and used her years of experience to help us know exactly when to list in the off-season. We had a packed open house and double digits of showings the first day, and then multiple competing offers even in the middle of Wisconsin winter! She helped us look at a few houses to buy and when we weren’t finding what we wanted in the market she helped us through the building process (even giving advice on resale items, when asked). Susan went above and beyond to support our family through this process (including helping watch/distract our toddler when needed!) and I recommend her to all my friends.
We could not recommend Susan highly enough. She was an absolute pleasure to work with and has a wonderful attitude and presence. She is extremely knowledgable and always thorough in answering questions. As first time home buyers, she really helped us through the process. She helped us hone in on what we were looking for and was always flexible when scheduling showings. She was patient and attentive. When we found the home that we wanted she helped us negotiate and understand everything about the process. We got our dream home and owe it all to her! I doubt we will be in the market for a new home any time soon, but if we are, we will definitely be working with Susan again!
We have bought and sold ten houses all over the country and Susan was one of the very best realtors we encountered. Her professionalism, knowledge of the Madison area and of the real estate process made for a very smooth transaction. I also appreciate that she is ethical and fun!
Working with Susan was an absolute pleasure. She has great knowledge of Madison neighborhoods and helped my wife and I secure the house we wanted in the location we desired. From day one, she was responsive, timely, and informative. She guided us through the entire process from going to open houses to writing our first offer. I highly recommend working with Susan when buying a home. She is fun, personable, and highly skilled at what she does!
Love her! Thorough, professional, great listener. Has sold several homes for us and always does a magnificent job. One home sold in a day, another in one week!
Susan was a great agent to work with when I purchased my property 1.5 years ago and I reached out without hesitation to work with her again when I needed to sell the property due to changing life circumstances. Her professionalism, knowledge, and support were exemplary during this process. She did an excellent job helping price and show my property such that it stood out from other units that were on the market in my neighborhood and also realized a sale price that I was happy with. I would recommend her wholeheartedly to anyone looking for a Real Estate Professional in the greater Madison area.
Susan went above and beyond in helping us sell our home, from coordinating landscapers, to recommending local electricians. She made the home-selling process so much easier for us. She is also genuinely nice to work with. Susan went out of her way to make sure our house was ready to sell. For instance, she let us borrow her own furniture to help us stage our house.
Working with Susan was an absolute pleasure. She has great knowledge of Madison neighborhoods and helped my wife and I secure the house we wanted in the location we desired. From day one, she was responsive, timely, and informative. She guided us through the entire process from going to open houses to writing our first offer. I highly recommend working with Susan when buying a home. She is fun, personable, and highly skilled at what she does!
As a first time home buyer I had many questions and moderate anxiety in regards to finding a Madison home in the current market. Susan's knowledge and experience allowed her to answer all of my questions clearly, and quieted my anxieties. I was deeply impressed with her responsiveness, professionalism and sincere desire to help me find a great home. She is a top-quality realtor with a genuine commitment to her clients. Thank you Susan, I love my home!
Everyone needs an agent like Susan on your side. Susan was professional, responsive, but mostly, she was clearly our advocate and represented our best interests. Susan represented us through some difficult negotiations and lender issues. This was our first home buying experience, and we could not have done it without Susan. Stop looking for other agents - Susan is the one!!
We worked with Susan when we purchased our condo. She was so easy to work with that we worked with her to sell our condo. She was responsive, helpful and we believe we got a fair price for our condo. We definitely recommend Susan as an agent.
We feel so fortunate to have found Susan as our real estate broker. We wanted to purchase a home in Madison from out-of-state, and Susan proved to be the most knowledgeable, professional, accommodating, and personable broker we could have wished for.

Purchasing from out-of-state meant that Susan needed to have a clear understanding of what we were looking for in terms of style, location, and price. We were not very familiar with Madison’s neighborhoods and were thankful for her experience with and knowledge of the area.

We were looking for an older house with character and found just that. The only thing that needed to be done was a kitchen remodel, and that in our mind was a plus. The remodel offered an opportunity to put our stamp on the house. She set us up with a kitchen designer and various contractors all of whom were exceptional.

Susan also found us a lender who was great to work with. The whole purchasing process went smoothly and quickly.

Susan is an excellent communicator, getting to the point quickly, and returning emails and phone calls promptly. This was so important in our long-distance communications. Susan is a problem solver. Our transaction was typical: issues arose suddenly that could have derailed the transaction. Susan shepherded the purchase through all obstacles with skill and patience. We feel very lucky to have had the opportunity to work with Susan and would recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell real estate in the Madison area.

Sarah & Andrew
Susan is the best agent we have every worked with. She is highly knowledgeable, well connected, very responsive, has an amazing sense of urgency, and is very genuine. Susan understood exactly what we were looking for and was great at ensuring we were first in line for new and even potential listings, but didn't waste our time showing houses that weren't right for us. When the perfect house came on the market we quickly (literally within days) found ourselves in a competitive bidding situation. Susan was absolutely brilliant and got us a house that is truly one in a million. Thank you Susan!